
The Dominick
Best for travelers who want a SoHo/Tribeca base with a seasonal rooftop pool, larger event spaces, and many on-site dining options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Dominick is a 46-story, 391-room luxury hotel in SoHo with a seasonal rooftop pool, multiple restaurants, and an on-site Sisley Spa — read this if you want downtown Manhattan energy, skyline pool time, and large event spaces. Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is a 5-star, design-forward luxury hotel in Midtown near MoMA and Rockefeller Center — read this if you prefer a polished, glamorous Midtown base with a full-service spa and indoor pool.
Updated · about 4.6 km apart

Best for travelers who want a SoHo/Tribeca base with a seasonal rooftop pool, larger event spaces, and many on-site dining options.

Best for visitors who want a Midtown location steps from MoMA and Rockefeller Center, a quieter luxury design hotel, and an indoor pool.
When The Dominick wins: Choose The Dominick if you want to stay in SoHo, prefer a rooftop pool and multiple on-site restaurants (including a rooftop gastropub), or need large event/wedding spaces and a fuller set of public amenities.
When Baccarat wins: Choose Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York if you want to be in Midtown within walking distance of MoMA, 5th Avenue, and Rockefeller Center, and you prefer an indoor pool and a design-focused, intimate luxury hotel.
Bottom line: Both are 5-star New York hotels with strong spas and clear personalities — pick The Dominick for downtown energy, rooftop pool days, and big event capacity; pick Baccarat for Midtown convenience, glamorous interiors, and an indoor pool.
| Category | The Dominick | Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary downtown luxury with SoHo gallery and shopping energy | Glamorous, design-led Midtown luxury |
| Location | 246 Spring Street — SoHo / Hudson Square (near Hudson River Park, NYU) | 28 West 53rd Street — Midtown (steps from MoMA & Rockefeller Center) |
| Size | Large — 391 rooms | Smaller — 114 guestrooms and residences |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; lead guest must be 21+ to check in; children under 13 stay free with an adult | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Pools | Seasonal outdoor rooftop pool (Terrace on 7), hotel-guests only | Indoor pool (listed as 1 indoor pool) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site outlets: Vestry (signature/Michelin-linked), Mezzanine, Cafe Mezz, El Ta'Koy (rooftop) | One main restaurant (Grand Salon) and a bar/lounge; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Sisley Spa — large bi-level spa with sauna, steam, Moroccan hammam; 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa on site, sauna/steam facilities listed; fitness facilities available |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, large event spaces (SoHo Ballroom), Sisley-branded spa | Design-forward interiors, proximity to major Midtown attractions (MoMA, Rockefeller Center) |
| Event capacity | About 12,000 sq ft of event space; largest ballroom ~3,900 sq ft (capacity listed up to 400) | Meeting rooms/meeting space: 1 listed meeting room in supplier data; overall event capacity smaller than The Dominick |
| Wi‑Fi & tech | Complimentary Wi‑Fi throughout | |
The Dominick sits at 246 Spring Street where SoHo meets Hudson Square, a short walk from galleries, boutiques, and Hudson River Park.
Choose The Dominick for a downtown Manhattan neighborhood base and proximity to SoHo galleries and boutiques.
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is on West 53rd Street in Midtown, a short walk from MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Choose Baccarat to be in the heart of Midtown, close to major museums, shopping, and theatre.
The Dominick offers 391 rooms and suites across multiple view types (Skyline, SoHi, Hudson Square) and family-friendly options.
The Dominick suits travelers who want lots of room options, family-friendly features, and skyline views.
Baccarat lists 114 guestrooms with tablet computers and designer toiletries, positioned as smaller and more intimate than The Dominick.
Baccarat is a better pick if you prefer a smaller, design-focused hotel with classic luxury room amenities.
The Dominick has several on-site dining options covering casual to fine dining, plus a rooftop gastropub and pool bar.
The Dominick provides more on-site dining variety and a rooftop dining scene.
Baccarat centers dining at Grand Salon (French cuisine) with a bar/lounge and limited room service hours.
Baccarat suits travelers who want classic French fine dining and a quieter, single-restaurant setup.
The Dominick's signature pool is a seasonal outdoor rooftop pool on the 7th-floor Terrace, reserved for hotel guests.
Choose The Dominick for rooftop pool time and skyline views during the hotel’s pool season.
Baccarat lists one indoor pool among its on-site amenities, available year-round according to supplier facts.
Pick Baccarat if you prefer an all-season indoor pool rather than a seasonal rooftop pool.
The Dominick houses Sisley Spa, a sizable bi-level spa with Moroccan hammam options and a 24-hour fitness center.
The Dominick is strong on wellness facilities and specialty spa rituals, including unique hammam access.
Baccarat also has a full-service on-site spa with treatment rooms, sauna and steam facilities listed among amenities.
Baccarat provides a formal, design-led spa experience in Midtown; it’s a strong pick if you want classic hotel spa services close to Midtown sights.

The Dominick — seasonal rooftop pool on Terrace on 7 with poolside bar and cabanas.

Baccarat — steps from MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue shopping.

The Dominick — roughly 12,000 sq ft of event space and a 3,900 sq ft ballroom option.

Baccarat — lists an indoor pool in its supplier amenities.
Both welcome families, but The Dominick explicitly notes children under 13 stay free with an adult and offers more family-oriented dining options; lead guest must be 21+ at both properties.
Baccarat is the easier Midtown base for theatres and Times Square-area shows; The Dominick is downtown and requires a subway or taxi ride to reach Midtown theatres.
The Dominick’s Sisley Spa includes private Moroccan hammams and signature rituals; Baccarat has a full-service spa but the dossier highlights The Dominick for hammam offerings.
Baccarat lists an indoor pool (year-round). The Dominick’s pool is seasonal (rooftop) and opens and closes depending on weather.
Explore how The Dominick stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·