
The Dominick
Best for contemporary downtown stays, rooftop pool time, and an on-site Sisley Spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Dominick is a 46-story, 391-room luxury hotel in SoHo with a seasonal rooftop pool, multiple restaurants, and a large Sisley Spa — read this if you want a contemporary downtown Manhattan base with strong wellness and rooftop amenities. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a storied Upper East Side grande-dame (188 rooms) with classic restaurants and close access to Central Park and the city’s major museums — read this if you prefer old‑school New York refinement and museum-side location.
Updated · about 8 km apart

Best for contemporary downtown stays, rooftop pool time, and an on-site Sisley Spa.

Best for classic Upper East Side luxury, museum access, and historic bars/restaurants near Central Park.
When The Dominick wins: pick The Dominick if you want a modern SoHo address, a seasonal rooftop pool and pool bar, Michelin-level dining options on-site, and a large branded spa (Sisley) with signature treatments and a 24-hour fitness center.
When The Carlyle wins: pick The Carlyle if you want a refined, traditional Upper East Side stay close to Central Park and the Met, prefer a hotel with a long-established New York identity (Bemelman's Bar, Rosewood affiliation), and value a quieter, museum-side base.
Bottom line: The Dominick is a contemporary, amenity-forward choice for downtown travelers who prioritize rooftop and spa experiences; The Carlyle is a classic, location-first option for visitors focused on museums, Madison Avenue, and an old‑New York hotel atmosphere.
| Category | The Dominick | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, downtown luxury with modern design and skyline views | Storied Upper East Side grande-dame with classic service and Art Deco details |
| Location | SoHo / Hudson Square — near galleries, boutiques, Hudson River Park | Upper East Side — a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size | 391 rooms across 46 stories | 188 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; lead guest must be 21+ | All ages welcome; lead guest/minimum age not published in supplier listing |
| Pools | Seasonal outdoor rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) for hotel guests only | No pool listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Vestry (Michelin-starred reporting), Mezzanine, Cafe Mezz, El Ta'Koy (rooftop/pool bar) | Two restaurants, Bemelman's Bar, coffee shop/cafe, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | Sisley Spa (11,000 sq ft bi-level spa, sauna, steam room, Moroccan hammam, public access), 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa (on-site) and fitness facilities listed |
| Known for | Rooftop pool and skyline views, large branded spa, contemporary dining | Classic New York address, proximity to Central Park and museums, Bemelman's Bar |
| Accessibility & transport | Close to Spring Street subway; valet parking available | Near Madison Avenue and Central Park; valet parking (surcharge) and limo/town car service available |
| Event & meeting space | About 12,000+ sq ft of event space, large ballrooms and penthouses for weddings/events | Number of meeting rooms - 1; multiple private dining and meeting options referenced |
The Dominick sits at 246 Spring Street in SoHo/Hudson Square, a short walk to galleries, boutiques and the Hudson River Park.
Choose The Dominick for a downtown, gallery-and-shopping neighborhood with faster access to nightlife and riverside walks.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street on the Upper East Side, steps from Madison Avenue and a short walk to Central Park and the Met.
Choose The Carlyle if you want museum access, Madison Avenue shopping, and a quieter, residential neighborhood feel.
The Dominick offers 391 rooms and suites across 46 floors with skyline or neighborhood views and multiple suite configurations.
The Dominick suits travelers who want contemporary, high-rise rooms with many suite configurations and modern in-room amenities.
The Carlyle lists 188 guestrooms and a variety of suites described for different needs and accessible options.
The Carlyle is a traditional luxury hotel with a range of classic room and suite categories, suitable for travelers seeking a museum-side base.
The Dominick’s dining scene mixes rooftop barfare with contemporary and Michelin-level offerings.
The Dominick is for guests who want a mix of casual rooftop dining and contemporary or Michelin-level hotel restaurants.
The Carlyle’s public listing highlights two restaurants, a cafe, and iconic hotel bars.
The Carlyle is best for travelers who value historic hotel dining and classic New York bars near museum row.
The Dominick has a seasonal rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) reserved for hotel guests and connected to a poolside bar.
If a rooftop pool and skyline pool deck matter, The Dominick is the clear downtown pick.
The Carlyle listing does not show a pool; its signature amenities are classic hotel public rooms, bars, and proximity to Central Park.
The Carlyle does not list a pool—choose it for park access and classic interiors rather than on-site swimming.
The Dominick emphasizes a large branded Sisley Spa, wellness treatments including Moroccan hammam, and rooftop nightlife options.
The Dominick is for guests who want an on-site, full-service spa plus rooftop evening energy.
The Carlyle offers full-service spa facilities and quieter nighttime options rooted in classic bars and hotel salons.
The Carlyle fits travelers seeking a quieter, refined evening scene and classic hotel bar experiences near museums.

The Dominick — seasonal Terrace on 7 rooftop pool and poolside bar with skyline views.

The Carlyle — steps from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

The Dominick — Sisley Spa (11,000 sq ft) with Moroccan hammam and signature treatments.

The Carlyle — long-standing Upper East Side grande-dame identity with notable bars and refined service.
The Carlyle — it’s a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art; The Dominick is downtown in SoHo and farther from museum row.
The Dominick — it has a seasonal rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) reserved for hotel guests. The Carlyle’s supplier listing does not show a pool.
The Dominick — Sisley Spa is a large, branded facility with signature treatments and a Moroccan hammam; The Carlyle lists a full-service spa but fewer published details in the supplier listing.
No — both hotels welcome guests of all ages in their listings. The Dominick requires the lead guest to be 21+ when checking in; The Carlyle’s listing does not indicate an adults-only policy.
Explore how The Dominick stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·