
The Dominick
Best for downtown neighborhoods, rooftop pool time, and an on-site Sisley Spa with unique treatments.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Dominick is a 46-story, 391-room luxury hotel in SoHo with a seasonal rooftop pool, Sisley-branded spa, and contemporary dining — good for travelers who want a downtown Manhattan base with rooftop life and spa access. Four Seasons Hotel New York is an ultra-luxury Midtown tower hotel on E 57th Street with individually decorated rooms and a well-known luxury service profile — read this if you’re weighing Midtown prestige and traditional luxury against a younger, design-forward SoHo option.
Updated

Best for downtown neighborhoods, rooftop pool time, and an on-site Sisley Spa with unique treatments.

Best for travelers who want a classic Midtown luxury address close to Central Park, 5th Avenue, and Rockefeller Center.
When The Dominick wins: Choose The Dominick if you want a SoHo/Tribeca base with a seasonal rooftop pool, a large branded spa (Sisley Spa) with rare treatments (private Moroccan hammam), and a contemporary downtown dining scene including El Ta'Koy and Mezzanine.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: Choose Four Seasons if you prioritize an ultra-luxury Midtown address close to Central Park and Fifth Avenue, a long-established luxury brand experience, and individually decorated rooms in a landmark Midtown location.
Bottom line: The Dominick is the downtown, design-forward pick with a prominent spa and rooftop pool; Four Seasons Hotel New York is the traditional Midtown luxury choice focused on location and brand prestige. Pick based on whether you want SoHo life and rooftop amenities (The Dominick) or Midtown proximity and Four Seasons’ signature service (Four Seasons).
| Category | The Dominick | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Design-forward, downtown SoHo luxury with rooftop life and contemporary restaurants | Ultra-luxury Midtown tower hotel with classic service and individually decorated rooms |
| Location | 246 Spring Street — SoHo / Hudson Square, near Hudson River Park and NYU | 57 E 57th Street — Midtown Manhattan, near Central Park and 5th Avenue |
| Size (rooms) | 391 rooms | 368 rooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; lead guest must be 21+; children under 13 stay free with parent | All ages welcome; lead guest minimum age 18 (check-in min age 18 listed in supplier data) |
| Pools | Seasonal rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) — hotel-guest access, wheelchair-accessible | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Vestry (Michelin-starred listing in some sources), Mezzanine, Cafe Mezz, El Ta'Koy rooftop bar | The Garden Restaurant (onsite) plus 24-hour room service and bar/lounge |
| Spa / wellness | Sisley Spa at The Dominick — 11,000 sq ft, Moroccan hammam, sauna/steam, signature rituals | Not published |
| Known for | Rooftop pool deck, Sisley Spa with unique treatments, SoHo location | Ultra-luxury brand, Midtown location near Central Park and 5th Avenue |
| Event / meeting space | About 12,000 sq ft of event space, multiple ballrooms and penthouse venues | Conference center and 12,120 sq ft of conference/meeting space listed |
| Accessibility & family features | Complimentary Wi‑Fi, pet policy (dogs under 25 lbs), family-friendly rooms and kids’ amenities noted | Complimentary wireless internet access listed (surcharge noted for wired/WiFi in supplier data), family-friendly features mentioned |
The Dominick sits at 246 Spring Street in SoHo/Hudson Square, a short walk from Hudson River Park and local galleries.
Choose The Dominick for a downtown, neighborhood stay with easy access to SoHo and the West Village.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is on E 57th Street in Midtown, placing you steps from 5th Avenue and a short walk to Central Park.
Choose Four Seasons for Midtown convenience and proximity to Central Park and flagship shopping streets.
The Dominick offers 391 rooms and suites across multiple view types and specialty suites, including spa and sauna suites.
The Dominick gives a variety of suite types and spa-linked rooms, good for travelers seeking on-site wellness or larger suites.
Four Seasons lists 368 individually decorated guestrooms, with multiple junior and Central Park–view suites.
Four Seasons focuses on individually styled rooms and high-end finishes, including Central Park–view suite options.
The Dominick’s restaurants emphasize contemporary American and Pacific Rim flavors with rooftop dining options.
The Dominick offers a varied and neighborhood-forward dining lineup, including a rooftop gastropub and fine-dining option.
Four Seasons provides classic hotel dining and a single main restaurant with 24-hour room service.
Four Seasons leans toward a focused, traditional hotel dining program centered on a single signature restaurant and room service.
The Dominick’s seasonal rooftop pool, Terrace on 7, is a central summertime feature with cabanas and a poolside bar.
Pick The Dominick if a downtown rooftop pool and poolside bar are priorities during warmer months.
Four Seasons supplier data does not publish a property pool detail.
Pool information for Four Seasons Hotel New York is not published in the provided supplier listing; verify directly with the hotel if a pool is a deciding factor.
The Dominick centers wellness on Sisley Spa plus 24-hour fitness and a rooftop social scene.
The Dominick is a strong choice for guests who want an expansive on-site spa and active rooftop nightlife.
Four Seasons emphasizes classic luxury services, 24-hour business center, and concierge-led experiences.
Four Seasons is well-suited to travelers who prefer traditional hotel services and attentive, brand-driven hospitality in Midtown.

The Dominick — seasonal Terrace on 7 rooftop pool and poolside bar reserved for hotel guests.

Four Seasons Hotel New York — steps from 5th Avenue, Madison Avenue, and close to Central Park.

The Dominick — Sisley Spa with Moroccan hammam, signature rituals, and an 11,000 sq ft footprint.

Four Seasons Hotel New York — an ultra-luxury Four Seasons property known for high-touch service and classic guest rooms.
Both accept families, but The Dominick explicitly notes kids’ amenities and children under 13 stay free; The Dominick may be a better pick for family stays downtown.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is much closer to Central Park and Midtown attractions; choose it if proximity to Central Park and Fifth Avenue matters.
Yes — Sisley Spa at The Dominick is open to the public. Four Seasons’ supplier listing does not publish spa details; check the hotel directly.
The Dominick has a seasonal rooftop pool reserved for hotel guests. Four Seasons’ supplier listing does not publish pool information, so confirm with them if a pool is essential.
Explore how The Dominick stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·