
The Dominick
Best for nightlife, big-group events, and a skyline rooftop pool experience in downtown Manhattan.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Dominick is a 46-story, 391-room SoHo luxury hotel with a seasonal rooftop pool, multiple restaurants, and a large on-site Sisley Spa — best for travelers who want downtown Manhattan energy, skyline views, and big-hotel facilities. The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is a refined Upper East Side, 100-room luxury property with a full-service spa and Casa Tua restaurant — best for travelers wanting a quieter, museum-and-Central-Park–focused stay.
Updated · about 6 km apart

Best for nightlife, big-group events, and a skyline rooftop pool experience in downtown Manhattan.

Best for museum runs, Madison Avenue shopping, and a quieter Upper East Side luxury base near Central Park.
When The Dominick wins: choose The Dominick if you want a larger hotel with multiple restaurants (including a Michelin-level dining history), a seasonal rooftop pool and cabanas, extensive event space, and a full-service Sisley Spa with signature treatments. It suits guests seeking downtown nightlife, larger meeting or wedding venues, or a hotel with wide food-and-drink options.
When The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel wins: choose The Surrey if you prefer a smaller, Upper East Side address steps from Central Park and the Met, a quieter neighborhood atmosphere, Frette sheets and a spa-focused experience tied to a long-standing Surrey name. It’s a good pick for museum-centered or Madison Avenue shopping stays where a refined, residential feel matters.
Bottom line: The Dominick is the better pick for scale, rooftop pool time, and a fuller dining/event program; The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is the better pick for a quieter, Central Park–adjacent Upper East Side stay with boutique scale and classic service.
| Category | The Dominick | The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Larger, contemporary downtown luxury; energetic SoHo base | Refined, residential Upper East Side luxury |
| Location | SoHo / Hudson Square — walkable to Hudson River Park, galleries, and nightlife | Upper East Side — 5-minute walk to Central Park and close to the Met |
| Size | 391 rooms (large) | 100 guestrooms (small/medium) |
| Check-in minimum age | Lead guest must be 21+; children allowed (under-13 stay free when sharing a room) | Lead guest must be 21+ (per supplier listing); children allowed |
| Pools / signature outdoor amenity | Seasonal rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) with poolside bar and cabanas; hotel-guest access | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets including Mezzanine (contemporary American), El Ta'Koy (Hawaiian-Asian rooftop), Cafe Mezz, Vestry (Michelin-level history), rooftop pool bar | Casa Tua (Italian restaurant) plus a bar/lounge and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | Sisley Spa — 11,000 sq ft, bi-level spa with sauna, steam room, salt chamber, Moroccan hammam and signature rituals; 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa with treatment rooms and spa services (details published: spa exists; size and signatures not published) |
| Known for | Rooftop pool and skyline views, large event/wedding spaces, signature Sisley spa treatments | Upper East Side location near Central Park and the Met, refined Surrey/Corinthia relaunch |
| Parking & transport | On-site valet parking (fee), close to subway access (Spring Street area) | Covered and secured parking, valet available (surcharge); limo/town car service available |
| Wi‑Fi & business | Complimentary Wi‑Fi throughout; meeting and event space up to ~12,000 sq ft | Free WiFi; smaller property scale for meetings (supplier lists concierge and event support) |
The Dominick sits in SoHo/Hudson Square, a downtown arts-and-shopping neighborhood with easy access to waterfront parks and nightlife.
Pick The Dominick for a downtown base close to SoHo galleries, nightlife, and waterfront walks.
The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is positioned on the Upper East Side steps from Madison Avenue and a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Choose The Surrey for museum visits, Central Park access, and a quieter, residential Manhattan stay.
The Dominick offers a broad room and suite mix across 391 rooms with skyline and neighborhood views.
The Dominick suits travelers wanting many room choices and skyline-facing suites downtown.
The Surrey has 100 guestrooms with refined fixtures (Frette sheets specified in supplier highlights) and a more intimate room count.
The Surrey fits guests who prefer a smaller, service-focused hotel with traditional luxury finishes.
The Dominick has multiple dining concepts including a Michelin-level dining history, casual cafe, and a rooftop restaurant/bar tied to the pool.
The Dominick offers variety for different meals and moods — from casual cafe to rooftop dining and fine-dining options.
The Surrey centers its dining on Casa Tua and an on-site bar/lounge, plus 24-hour room service.
The Surrey is ideal for guests who want a focused, classic restaurant option and room service near museum hours.
The Dominick’s seasonal rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) is a clear outdoor amenity with skyline views and a connected pool bar.
Choose The Dominick if a rooftop pool and skyline poolside time matter to your NYC visit.
Surrey’s supplier listing emphasizes proximity to Central Park and a full-service spa but does not publish a pool.
If pool time is central to your plans, the supplier listing for The Surrey does not confirm an on-site pool.
The Dominick pairs a large Sisley-branded spa and 24-hour fitness center with downtown nightlife and bars.
The Dominick combines extensive wellness facilities with direct access to SoHo nightlife and rooftop evenings.
The Surrey emphasizes refined pampering with a full-service spa and a quieter Upper East Side evening scene.
Pick The Surrey for calm, spa-forward evenings and proximity to classical-culture nightlife rather than downtown bars.

The Dominick — seasonal rooftop pool with cabanas, skyline views, and a connected pool bar.

The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel — a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

The Dominick — large Sisley Spa with Moroccan hammam and signature rituals.

The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel — smaller room count and Upper East Side setting for a less frenetic stay.
The Dominick — it has a seasonal rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) reserved for hotel guests. Surrey’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
The Surrey — it’s about a 5-minute walk to Central Park and roughly 6 minutes to the Metropolitan Museum of Art per the supplier highlights.
The Dominick’s Sisley Spa is open to the public for treatments; Surrey has a full-service spa but the supplier listing does not indicate whether non-guests can book (contact the hotel to confirm).
Both hotels allow children, but both list a lead-guest check-in minimum age of 21. The Dominick specifically notes children under 13 stay free when sharing a room with a parent or guardian.
Explore how The Dominick stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·