
The Dominick
Best for skyline-view rooftop pool time, a large branded spa (Sisley) and dining tied to a contemporary downtown neighborhood.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Dominick is a 46-story, 391-room SoHo luxury hotel with a seasonal rooftop pool, multiple restaurants, and an 11,000 sq ft Sisley Spa — for travelers who want modern SoHo design, skyline views, and a downtown base. The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York is a landmark Fifth Avenue luxury hotel facing Central Park, best for travelers who prioritize a classic Upper East Side address and a traditional luxury hotel experience.
Updated

Best for skyline-view rooftop pool time, a large branded spa (Sisley) and dining tied to a contemporary downtown neighborhood.

Best for a classic Central Park address and a landmark, Fifth Avenue luxury-hotel experience close to Midtown shopping and museums.
When The Dominick wins: pick The Dominick if you want a contemporary SoHo base with a seasonal rooftop pool, a large Sisley-branded spa with unique treatments (including a Moroccan hammam), multiple casual and fine-dining on-site outlets, and direct access to downtown galleries, Hudson River Park, and neighborhood nightlife.
When The Pierre wins: choose The Pierre if a Fifth Avenue, Central Park–facing location and a landmark, old‑world luxury hotel are your priorities — it’s steps from Bergdorf Goodman, the park, and Midtown cultural sights.
Bottom line: The Dominick is the downtown, modern luxury pick with a focus on spa and rooftop amenities; The Pierre is the classic Fifth Avenue luxury option for travelers who want to be near Central Park and Midtown sights.
| Category | The Dominick | The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary SoHo high-rise, modern design and skyline views | Historic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel, classic service style |
| Location | 246 Spring Street (SoHo/Hudson Square) — walkable to Hudson River Park and NYU | 2 E 61st St (Fifth Avenue, beside Central Park and near Bergdorf Goodman) |
| Size | 391 rooms across 46 stories | 189 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; lead guest must be 21+; children under 13 stay free with parent | All ages welcome; Not published |
| Pools | Seasonal outdoor rooftop pool (Terrace on 7), guest-only, wheelchair-accessible | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | El Ta'Koy (Hawaiian-Asian rooftop), Mezzanine (contemporary American), Cafe Mezz (café); in-room dining available | Perrine (French fine-dining) + 1 bar/lounge and room service |
| Spa / wellness | Sisley Spa — 11,000 sq ft, sauna, steam, salt chamber, Moroccan hammam, public bookings allowed | Not published |
| Known for | Large branded Sisley Spa, rooftop pool and skyline dining | Landmark hotel on Fifth Avenue facing Central Park |
| Event space | About 12,000 sq ft of event space; SoHo Ballroom (3,900 sq ft) and high-capacity options | Conference/meeting space listed (small overall — 22 sq ft shown in supplier listing), meeting rooms available |
| Wi‑Fi & tech | Complimentary Wi‑Fi in rooms & public areas | |
The Dominick sits at 246 Spring Street where SoHo, Hudson Square and TriBeCa meet, putting galleries, boutiques and the Hudson River Park within a short walk.
Choose The Dominick for a downtown neighborhood stay and easy access to SoHo’s shops and riverside walks.
The Pierre sits on Fifth Avenue beside Central Park, a short walk to Midtown shopping, museums and Rockefeller Center.
Choose The Pierre if you want a Fifth Avenue address and immediate access to Central Park and Midtown attractions.
The Dominick has 391 rooms and a variety of suites and skyline views across its 46 floors.
Expect high-floor skyline rooms and many suite layouts tailored for couples and family groups.
The Pierre offers 189 traditionally styled rooms with options including Park View, City View, and multiple tiers of deluxe and signature rooms and suites.
The Pierre is the pick for travelers who want traditional luxury rooms with Park View options on Fifth Avenue.
The Dominick offers a three-part dining program from rooftop plates to a contemporary American restaurant and a daytime café.
The Dominick covers casual, scenic rooftop dining and an all-day restaurant for neighborhood and hotel guests.
The Pierre lists Perrine as its on-site fine-dining restaurant along with a bar/lounge and room service.
The Pierre suits travelers who prefer a single, classic in-house fine-dining restaurant plus immediate access to Fifth Avenue dining.
The Dominick’s headline amenity is its seasonal Terrace on 7 rooftop pool with a connected poolside bar and cabana options.
Pick The Dominick if an on-site rooftop pool and skyline deck are important to your stay.
The Pierre’s supplier listing emphasizes its Central Park and Fifth Avenue location rather than an on-site pool.
Choose The Pierre for immediate Central Park access; confirm pool availability directly if that matters to you.
The Dominick features Sisley Spa, a major part of its wellness offering, plus a 24-hour fitness center.
The Dominick is the wellness choice for on-site, high-capacity spa offerings and an active rooftop scene.
The Pierre’s supplier listing highlights concierge, business services and classic hotel amenities; spa details are not published in the supplied listing.
The Pierre provides traditional luxury services and event support; verify spa/wellness options directly with the hotel.

The Dominick — seasonal rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) connected to El Ta'Koy with skyline views and poolside cabanas.

The Pierre — Fifth Avenue address steps from Central Park and close to Bergdorf Goodman and Midtown museums.

The Dominick — Sisley Spa is an 11,000 sq ft, bi-level facility with signature rituals and Moroccan hammam offerings.

The Pierre — positioned as a historic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel for travelers who want a traditional Upper East Side stay.
The Pierre is steps from Central Park on Fifth Avenue; The Dominick is downtown in SoHo and not near the park.
The Dominick has a major on-site Sisley Spa with signature rituals and Moroccan hammam treatments. The Pierre’s supplier listing doesn’t publish spa details, so contact them directly if a spa is essential.
Yes — both properties accept families. The Dominick notes children under 13 stay free when sharing a room with a parent; The Pierre’s supplier listing indicates up to three children 5 and under stay free when using existing bedding.
Choose The Dominick for a rooftop pool and poolside dining at El Ta'Koy. The Pierre’s listing does not publish a rooftop/pool amenity.
Explore how The Dominick stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·