
The Dominick
Best for downtown/SoHo access, a rooftop pool scene, and a large on-site Sisley Spa (including Moroccan hammam).
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Dominick is a 46-story, 391-room luxury hotel in SoHo with a seasonal rooftop pool, Sisley Spa, and contemporary restaurants — best for travelers who want downtown Manhattan energy and skyline views. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a high-rise luxury hotel at Columbus Circle with Central Park and river views, a full spa, and two bars — read this if you want a more midtown, park-facing luxury stay.
Updated

Best for downtown/SoHo access, a rooftop pool scene, and a large on-site Sisley Spa (including Moroccan hammam).

Best for views of Central Park, a midtown location near Lincoln Center and Columbus Circle, and an established luxury spa program.
When The Dominick wins: choose The Dominick if you want to stay in SoHo/Hudson Square with easy access to galleries, downtown nightlife, and a seasonal rooftop pool with a connected bar and casual Pacific‑Rim dining.
When Mandarin Oriental wins: pick Mandarin Oriental, New York if proximity to Central Park, Columbus Circle, and more midtown sightseeing matters, or if you prioritize a high-rise hotel with river/park views and a longstanding spa reputation.
Bottom line: both are five-star Manhattan options with notable spas and strong dining; pick The Dominick for a SoHo address and rooftop pool culture, and Mandarin Oriental for a Central Park/Columbus Circle address and classic park/river vistas.
| Category | The Dominick | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary SoHo luxury with a lively rooftop scene and downtown access | High-rise, polished Midtown luxury with park and river-facing rooms |
| Location | 246 Spring Street — SoHo / Hudson Square, close to galleries and Hudson River Park | 80 Columbus Circle at 60th Street — steps from Columbus Circle and Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | 391 rooms | 244 guestrooms |
| Guest rating / stars | 5 stars; recognized as an AAA Five‑Diamond property in SoHo (per sources) | 5 stars; guest rating 9.2 (supplier listing) |
| Pools | Seasonal outdoor rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) for hotel guests only; wheelchair-accessible | Indoor pool (1) listed in supplier amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Mezzanine (contemporary American), El Ta'Koy (Hawaiian‑Asian rooftop), Cafe Mezz, Library lounge | MO Lounge and other on-site dining; 2 bars/lounges (supplier listing) |
| Spa & wellness | Sisley Spa at The Dominick — 11,000 sq ft bi-level spa, Moroccan hammam, sauna/steam, 24‑hr fitness | Full-service spa, indoor pool, sauna; well-known spa reputation (supplier listing) |
| Known for | Downtown location, rooftop pool, Sisley-branded spa, Michelin-starred Vestry (reported) | Central Park proximity, high-rise views, strong spa and service reputation |
| Family & age policy | All ages welcome; lead guest must be 21+; children under 13 stay free with parent | All ages welcome (adultsOnly: false in provided data) |
| Parking & transport notes | Valet parking available (surcharge); near Spring Street subway access | Valet parking (surcharge) and airport shuttle available (surcharge) |
The Dominick sits at 246 Spring Street where SoHo meets Hudson Square and TriBeCa.
Choose The Dominick for a downtown SoHo/West Village base and easy access to galleries and the Hudson River.
Mandarin Oriental is positioned at Columbus Circle with very close access to Central Park and midtown sights.
Pick Mandarin Oriental for midtown convenience and immediate access to Central Park and cultural venues.
The Dominick offers 391 rooms across many skyline- and neighborhood-view configurations.
The Dominick suits travelers seeking larger room inventory and skyline or neighborhood views downtown.
Mandarin Oriental has a range of Hudson and Central Park view rooms and suites.
Mandarin Oriental is ideal if park- or river-facing rooms and high-rise views are a priority.
Dining at The Dominick ranges from casual rooftop plates to a contemporary second-floor restaurant.
The Dominick mixes casual rooftop dining and a formal contemporary restaurant for different moods.
Mandarin Oriental lists MO Lounge and other on-site dining outlets and two bars/lounges.
Mandarin Oriental works well for guests wanting classic hotel lounges and convenient midtown dining.
The Dominick's distinctive seasonal amenity is its rooftop pool on Terrace on 7.
If a seasonal rooftop pool with skyline views matters, The Dominick is the clear option.
Mandarin Oriental offers an indoor pool as part of its on-site amenities.
Choose Mandarin Oriental if you prefer a year-round indoor pool and spa experience over a seasonal rooftop pool.
Wellness at The Dominick centers on the large Sisley Spa plus a 24-hour fitness center.
The Dominick is strong for spa-focused stays and late-night dining/drink options in SoHo.
Mandarin Oriental pairs a full-service spa with midtown nightlife options around Columbus Circle.
Mandarin Oriental is a solid pick for guests who want spa services plus easy access to midtown cultural evenings.

The Dominick — Terrace on 7 is a seasonal rooftop pool with cabanas and a connected poolside bar reserved for hotel guests.

Mandarin Oriental, New York — located at Columbus Circle with Central Park and river-facing room categories.

The Dominick — stay in SoHo/Hudson Square for galleries, boutiques, and nearby Hudson River Park.

Mandarin Oriental, New York — lists an indoor pool and midtown positioning suited to park/museum/theater itineraries.
Mandarin Oriental, New York is steps from Columbus Circle and Central Park; choose it for park-facing rooms and quick access to park paths.
The Dominick has a seasonal rooftop pool on Terrace on 7 reserved for hotel guests; Mandarin Oriental lists an indoor pool instead.
Both hotels welcome families. The Dominick allows children under 13 to stay free with a parent (lead guest must be 21+). Mandarin Oriental is listed as all-ages (adultsOnly: false).
The Dominick's Sisley Spa is open to the public for bookings; Mandarin Oriental also lists full spa services but check the hotel for public access and reservation policies.
Explore how The Dominick stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·