
The Dominick
Best for skyline rooftop pool access, a large on-site Sisley Spa, and family-friendly amenities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Dominick is a 46-story, 391-room SoHo luxury hotel with a seasonal rooftop pool, full spa, and family-friendly services — a good pick for travelers who want a central SoHo base with skyline pool time and a large spa. The New York EDITION is a stylish 5-star hotel near Madison Square Park with fashion-forward design, The Clocktower restaurant, and meeting space — aimed at design-conscious guests and business travelers.
Updated · about 1.6 km apart

Best for skyline rooftop pool access, a large on-site Sisley Spa, and family-friendly amenities.

Best for design-conscious travelers who want a fashionable hotel near Madison Square Park and strong meeting/restaurant options.
When The Dominick wins: choose The Dominick if you want a SoHo location with a seasonal rooftop pool, a large Sisley Spa (including a Moroccan hammam), multiple on-site dining outlets, and family/pet-friendly policies.
When The New York EDITION wins: pick The New York EDITION if you prefer a Madison Square/Flatiron address, contemporary EDITION-style design, a central position for Flatiron and nearby business districts, and a hotel restaurant and bars that suit style-focused travelers.
Bottom line: both are 5-star Manhattan hotels in different neighborhoods. Pick The Dominick for spa, rooftop pool, and a SoHo vibe; pick The New York EDITION for a fashionable Flatiron/Madison Square Park base and a compact, design-forward experience.
| Category | The Dominick | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, full-service SoHo hotel condominum with a resort-like spa and rooftop pool | Stylish, lifestyle luxury hotel near Madison Square Park with EDITION branding |
| Location | 246 Spring Street (SoHo / Hudson Square), walkable to galleries, Hudson River Park, NYU | 5 Madison Avenue (Madison Square Park / Flatiron) |
| Size | 391 rooms across 46 stories | 271 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; lead guest must be 21+; children under 13 stay free with a guardian | All ages welcome; lead guest minimum not published by supplier listing |
| Pools | Seasonal outdoor rooftop pool (Terrace on 7) for hotel guests only; wheelchair-accessible | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets: Mezzanine (contemporary American), Cafe Mezz, El Ta'Koy (Hawaiian-Asian) plus rooftop pool bar and Library lounge | The Clocktower restaurant, 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | Sisley Spa (11,000 sq ft) with sauna, steam room, salt chamber, Moroccan hammam and signature treatments | Spa services on site (name and details not published in supplier listing) |
| Meetings & events | About 12,000 sq ft of event space (ballrooms and penthouses) for up to ~500 guests; large ballroom options | 2100 sq ft of conference space and 5 meeting rooms |
| Key nearby sights | Hudson River Park, NYU, Washington Square Park, High Line (~1 mile) | Steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building; ~0.8 mi to Empire State Building |
| Wi‑Fi & front desk | Complimentary Wi‑Fi, 24-hour front desk | |
The Dominick sits at 246 Spring Street where SoHo meets Hudson Square and TriBeCa, a short walk to galleries, boutiques and the Hudson River Park.
A downtown base for shopping, galleries and waterfront walks.
The New York EDITION is on Madison Avenue beside Madison Square Park, putting you in the Flatiron business-and-design district.
A compact, central location for Flatiron and midtown neighborhoods.
The Dominick has 391 rooms across 46 stories with many suite options and accessible features.
Large inventory with varied suite and view options, suitable for families and groups.
The New York EDITION lists 271 air‑conditioned rooms and a range of accessible room types.
A mid-sized, design-forward room inventory with accessible options.
Dining at The Dominick spans a modern American restaurant, a daytime cafe, and a Hawaiian-Asian rooftop gastropub plus poolside service.
A varied on-site dining scene from casual to elevated, including a rooftop dining-and-bar setup.
The New York EDITION features The Clocktower restaurant and two bars/lounges, plus 24-hour room service.
A concise, fashion-oriented food-and-drink offering in a design-led setting.
The Dominick's signature amenity is its seasonal rooftop pool, Terrace on 7, with cabanas and a connected pool bar.
Choose The Dominick if a rooftop pool is an important part of your stay.
The New York EDITION emphasizes stylish city living; supplier listing notes restaurant, bars and spa services on site.
A city-center hotel that focuses on design, dining and meeting spaces rather than a rooftop pool experience (not published).
The Dominick provides a large Sisley Spa, plus a 24-hour fitness center and a Library lounge for quieter evenings.
Strong wellness focus with an extensive spa program and around-the-clock fitness.
The New York EDITION lists spa services on site and two bars/lounges for drinks and social nights.
A stylish hotel with evening bars and some wellness offerings; spa details are not fully published in the supplier listing.

The Dominick — Terrace on 7 is a seasonal rooftop pool reserved for hotel guests with cabanas and skyline views.

The Dominick — Sisley Spa is an 11,000 sq ft bi-level facility with a Moroccan hammam and signature treatments.

The New York EDITION — steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building for midtown access.

The New York EDITION — EDITION-branded styling, smart public spaces, and a focused restaurant/bar offering.
The Dominick — it has a seasonal rooftop pool reserved for hotel guests. The New York EDITION's supplier listing does not publish pool information.
The Dominick explicitly welcomes children (under-13s stay free with a guardian) and lists family-friendly dining and amenities. The New York EDITION accepts all ages per its public positioning but the Dominick is more overtly family-oriented in its policies.
The Dominick — Sisley Spa is detailed as an 11,000 sq ft, bi-level facility with multiple signature treatments and hammam experiences. The New York EDITION lists spa services on site but does not publish spa size or a spa name in the supplier listing.
Both hotels have meeting space: The Dominick offers roughly 12,000 sq ft across multiple rooms (including large ballrooms and penthouses); The New York EDITION lists about 2,100 sq ft and five meeting rooms. For larger events, The Dominick is the stronger option.
Explore how The Dominick stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·